Acrylic is not the best choice for the newly pierced belly buttons as it is somewhat porous which can harbor infection. Just wait til you heal and you'll be set.

Tip: Don't overtighten as acrylic can crack into several pieces.

Browse below:

50 Mixed Ball Acrylic Steel Belly Navel Barbell Bars Rings Body Piercing    US $5.00

New 14 Gauge 7 16 Acrylic Plastic Belly Ring Steel Color Acrylic Ball 5 8mm    US $.99

Set of 62 Assorted Acrylic 316L Surgical Belly Navel Bars 11mm JOB LOT    US $15.73

Solid 14GA 316L Surgical Steel Acrylic Navel Ring    US $.01

V083 Acrylic Belly Naval Rings Barbells 100 YOUR CHOICE    US $14.95

V079 Acrylic Belly Naval Rings Barbells 30 YOUR CHOICE    US $7.95

100 Licenced Playboy Stainless Acrylic Curved Bellies    US $149.00

8G 6G 4G 2G 0G 00G COMPLETE EAR TAPER PLUG STRETCHER SET KIT CLEAR ACRYLIC    US $19.87

Navel Belly Button Bar Ring Leopard Print Acrylic Balls Piercing 594    US $2.25

V081 Acrylic Belly Naval Rings Barbells 50 YOUR CHOICE    US $9.95

BIO FLEX NAVEL RING UV ACRYLIC BALL BELLY BUTTON RING YOUR CHOICE OF COLOR    US $.99

FLUORESCENT ACRYLIC DISCO BALL NAVEL RING BELLY BUTTON RING PICK YOUR COLOR    US $.99

PINK STARBURST ACRYLIC NAVEL RING 14G 3 8 BELLY BUTTON RING    US $.99

N80 20pc UV Acrylic Nose Studs 20g Nostril Rings    US $9.99

W091 Acrylic Belly Naval Rings Bars Barbell Hearts Shape Design Lot of 10 Colors    US $5.95

100Pcs 14G UV Acrylic Belly Ring Navel Ring Piercings Belly Ring Free Shipping    US $28.78

20 Mixed Belly Bars Steel Bar Coloured Acrylic Balls Navel Body Piercing 14g    US $8.68

W031 Acrylic Belly Naval Rings Stripes Design LOT of 10    US $5.95

11 Licenced Playboy Stainless Acrylic Curved Bellies    US $24.99

W053 Acrylic Belly Naval Rings Checkered Design LOT 10    US $5.95

100 Ball Flexi Acrylic Steel Mixed Belly Navel Barbell Bars Rings Body Piercing    US $1.89

V085 Acrylic Belly Naval Rings Barbells 150 of YOUR CHOICE Flowers Heart Stripes    US $19.95

Closeout 4 Pcs Acrylic Knot Design Rings BX101    US $1.99

Closeout 4 Pcs Acrylic Design Rings BX104    US $1.99

Closeout 4 Pcs Acrylic Design Rings BX102    US $1.99

Closeout 10 Pcs Acrylic Teddy Bear Design Rings BX103    US $1.99

Closeout 4 Pcs Acrylic Design Rings BX100    US $1.00

LEOPARD SKIN PRINT BELLY NAVEL RING ACRYLIC BALL BUTTON PIERCING JEWELRY B42    US $2.75

Closeout Lot of of 7 Acrylic Belly Design Rings BX023    US $1.49

100 EXCLUSIVE PREMIUM STYLE ACRYLIC BELLY BUTTON RINGS    US $100.00

W095 Acrylic Belly Rings Bars Barbells Stripes Shape Design LOT 10 colors Rasta    US $5.95

Acrylic Heart Reversed Belly Ring with Gems 32700 GR    US $8.99

Acrylic Heart Reversed Belly Ring with Cz Gem 32700 B    US $8.99

W043 Acrylic Belly Naval Rings Clover Shape LOT of 10    US $5.95

Acrylic Colorful Initial Belly Button Ring 34810    US $6.99

W063 Acrylic Belly Naval Rings Bars Cannabis Marijuana Weed Pot Leaf 10 Colors    US $5.95

500 14g 7 16 Acrylic Ball Flexible PTFE NAVEL BELLY    US $99.99

Closeout 3 Pcs Acrylic Multi Heart Belly Rings BX027    US $1.49

25 MIXED 14g TOP QUALITY ACRYLIC BELLY RINGS STAINLESS STEEL BAR US SELLER    US $7.99

Lot Of 13 Stainless Double Acrylic Gem Navel Rings    US $9.80

Wholesale Lot 4 PCS Navel Belly Button Ring Acrylic Facited Disco Ball 422    US $4.45

PEACE Acrylic Belly Naval Rings 7 PACK 14g 316L SS    US $5.99

CZ Crystal Gem Acrylic Flexi Navel Belly Bar Choose Your Colour    US $1.56

Lot Of 10 Stainless Single Acrylic Gem Post For Piercing    US $8.80

20 Assorted Belly Button Navel Rings 14g 7 16 Acrylic 8 mm Ball Pretty Exciting    US $16.95

UV FLEXI PLASTIC ACRYLIC STAR BALL NAVEL BAR ALL COLOURS belly piercing    US $1.56

500 16g 3 8 Eyebrow PTFE Bent Barbells with Acrylic    US $99.99

Closeout Lot of 4 Acrylic Belly Design Rings BX098    US $1.49

Closeout Lot of 4 Acrylic Belly Design Rings BX095    US $1.49

TWIST Black Marble Acrylic NAVEL BELLY Body Jewelry    US $3.50

Closeout Lot of of 5 Acrylic Belly Design Rings BX024    US $1.49

Lot Of 11 Stainless Double Acrylic Gem Straight Post Navel Ear Pierced Earring    US $9.80

6 PCS UV Acrylic Glow in the Dark BellyRing Navelw495    US $5.49

DOUBLE JEWELLED STEEL UV ACRYLIC NAVEL BAR ALL SIZES COLOURS piercing    US $2.37

Acrylic Top Mount Female GAY PRIDE Belly Ring 14g 316L    US $2.99

Choice of TWO Acrylic Handpainted Star Belly Ring 14g316L    US $2.99

Choice of Bright Neon Acrylic Heart Belly Ring 14g 316L    US $2.49

Choice of Bright Neon Acrylic Star Belly Ring 14g 316L    US $2.49